THE HUNGER GAMES: MOCKINGJAY
Part I 3.0***
It seems that it has become an unofficial Hollywood money-making policy that,
when adapting successful young adult novels
for the screen, the last entry in the series must be divided into two
separate films. The Harry
Potter series did this to great financial effect, as did The Twilight Saga.
The upside to this approach is that filmmakers don't have to pare down
the final book as much; they can include more of the story by spreading it out
a little. The downside is that the first half of the finale tends to be a lot
of setup for a payoff that comes about a year later. That can make it a
less-than-satisfying experience in and of itself. Mockingjay – Part 1 suffers from that
downside but still offers something new to the franchise which helps
mitigate the half-a-story syndrome.
The
plot picks up with Katniss Everdeen (Jennifer Lawrence) in District 13 after
the spectacular ending to the last Games.
President Coin of District 13 (Julianne Moore) and former Game maker Plutarch
Heavensbee (Philip Seymour Hoffman), who rescued her, are leading a rebellion
against the oppressive Capitol. They want Katniss to be the face of that
rebellion. She initially resists, but then learns that President Snow (Donald
Sutherland) has Peeta (Josh Hutcherson) at the Capitol, and is using him to campaign against
the rebellion. In order to save Peeta, Katniss reluctantly agrees to become the
public symbol of the rebellion. Katniss is filmed
in a series of dramatic propaganda TV videos
designed to encourage everyone in the remaining districts to rise up.
The
movie is a worthy entry in the series because it does something very important.
Mockingjay – Part 1
is an astute examination of a political rebellion and how masses are motivated
and manipulated. The film explores
concepts of propaganda, myth-making and the ethics of deciding when/how to put
people in danger. It's fascinating stuff which makes the relative lack of
big-ticket action go down a little easier while also sergving as a huge promo for the big 2015 finale.
As always, Jennifer Lawrence anchors it all, bringing raw emotion to her
role. Political machinations can be interesting in and of themselves, yet having
such a relatable heroine gives them genuine weight here. Lawrence provides
Katniss with just the right amount of hesitation. She may not be fighting for
her life this time, but she's most definitely fighting for her soul and her
morality, so the stakes are still high.
The look and feel of the film is different from the first
two. There is much less action ( no games and none
of the spectacle) and the Capitol scenes are brief and mostly in tight
shots focusing on Snow, Peeta, or the unctuous interviewer Caesar Flickerman
(Stanley Tucci). We do get a sense of the sparse military/living conditions in
District 13, where Haymitch (Woody Harrelson) can’t get any alcohol drinks, Effie (Elizabeth Banks) can’t get any
make-up or costumes, and even Katniss
has to demand that her sister be allowed to keep her cat.
Another problem with the movie is the story doesn’t
come to a satisfying end but rather to an abrupt intermission-type ending with a I year wait for the
finale. Those who haven’t read the books will likely feel frustrated and those
who haven’t seen the other movies shouldn’t even bother.
Clark